Soft peanut butter cookies filled with butterscotch chips and finished with a sprinkle of sea salt. Sweet, salty and absolutely perfect!
If there was ever a time to get excited about a peanut butter cookie, THIS IS IT! Oh my gosh, you guys – these Peanut Butter Butterscotch Cookies are to die for.
This here is your warning. Prepare to lick beaters, nibble bites of dough from the bowl, and consume every last crumb of this peanut buttery-butterscotch goodness.
You know I love cookies – M&M Cookies – Trail Mix Cookies – Coffee Toffee Cookies – Cookie Pie! But, I would venture to say that these Peanut Butter Butterscotch Cookies have shot to the top of my list. I can’t wait for you to taste them.
Peanut Butter Butterscotch Cookies
There are a few things that set this cookie recipe apart from other peanut butter cookies I have had.
- These cookies are loaded with peanut butter flavor. No bland barely-there peanut butter in here. Sweet and salty peanut buttery goodness in every single bite.
- Brown sugar, and lots of it. The combo of peanut butter and brown sugar is a match made in heaven. I like to use more brown sugar than white in this recipe to ensure a soft, tender, perfectly sweet cookie.
- Salt! This is the key. Sprinkle the top of these cookies with a little sea salt right after they come out of the oven. This creates a salty-sweet balance that will make you swoon with every bite.
- Butterscotch Chips! Duh, why had I never thought of this before? Butterscotch chips aren’t just for oatmeal cookies, they are a tasty complement to peanut butter, and they take these cookies over the top! Note: These are my favorite butterscotch chips.
Tips for making cookies
Here are my top three cookie baking tips:
- Butter should be softened just slightly. Not just about to melt and not so soft that it’s lost shape. You should be able to lightly press your finger into it and it should mostly hold shape. An hour or two at room temp is usually all I need. Butter that is too soft makes cookies that spread thin. If you accidentally over-soften your butter, proceed with the recipe but refrigerate the dough for 1 hour.
- Do NOT overbake your cookies. I can’t stress this enough. When you remove the cookie sheet from the oven, the cookies should be slightly underdone in the very center. The cookies will continue to cook as they sit on the baking sheet.
- Cookies need salt! We don’t want our cookies to be salty, but we want enough salt to balance the sweetness. Butterscotch chips are very, very sweet, so salt is absolutely necessary to create a well rounded flavor for these cookies. There is a little salt in the cookie dough, as well as additional salt sprinkled on top after baking. Flaky Maldon Sea Salt is my absolute favorite for finishing these cookies, but regular sea salt works fine, too.
Prefer chocolate chips instead of butterscotch chips? Go for it! I’m thinking just about any “chip” would be good in here (dark chocolate, white chocolate, peanut butter).
NEVER MISS A RECIPE!
SUBSCRIBE to our free EMAIL LIST – LIKE us on FACEBOOK – Follow on INSTAGRAM
Peanut Butter Butterscotch Cookies
Soft peanut butter cookies filled with butterscotch chips and finished with a sprinkle of sea salt. Sweet, salty and absolutely perfect!
Ingredients
- 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons all purpose flour
- 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 10 tablespoons unsalted butter softened (1 1/4 sticks)
- 2/3 cup creamy peanut butter at room temp
- 1/4 cup granulated sugar
- 2/3 cup brown sugar packed
- 1 large egg
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 cup butterscotch chips divided
- sea salt (I like flaky Maldon sea salt) for topping
Instructions
Preheat oven to 350°F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper and set aside.
In a medium bowl, combine flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt and set side.
In a large bowl, using a hand mixer or stand mixer, beat butter and peanut butter until smooth and combined. Add both sugars and beat to combine. Beat in egg and vanilla extract. Add the flour mixture all at once and beat until just combined. Stir in about 2/3 cup of butterscotch chips (reserving the rest for topping the cookies).
Scoop the dough into balls (I use a 1 1/2 tablespoon scoop), and place a couple inches apart on the prepared baking sheets. Press a few of remaining butterscotch chips on top of the dough balls. Bake for 8-11 minutes, until the edges are light golden brown, but the center is still slightly underdone. Immediately sprinkle with sea salt, and place the sheets on wire racks to cool. Repeat with remaining dough, allowing the cookie sheets to cool COMPLETELY before placing dough on them.
My kids will go nuts over these I guess I know what my next cookie will be for dessert this week thanks
Two of my favorite put together?! Amazing! I never would have thought of combining the two but it sounds so good!
This sounds like such a great combination. I know my husband would love these cookies as butterscotch is his thing.
I love peanut butter cookies and the combination with butterscotch sounds amazing! I’ll have to try this recipe soon!
Peanut butter cookies are always popular in my house. Love the inclusion of butterscotch too – such delicious flavours.
Wow, this sounds so totally yummy! I love peanut butter cookies and I love butterscotch. Thanks also for the baking tips.
OMG these look SO delicious!! Definitely want to try these.
Oh my God! I am making these this week! I love peanut butter cookies!
these look absolutely delicious! i love peanut butter and butterscotch so pretty sure I’d love these!!
This recipe looks soo good – it was making me hungry just reading it. I especially love the tip to add sea salt to the top of the cookie – I would have never thought of that, but it sounds so good!
I do love my chocolate chips but these look perfect!! I can’t wait to try them…. just gotta get all the ingredients now 🙂 yummy, yummy!
oh my gosh I LOVE this idea! Sounds so so yummy (and can totally relate to eating dough out of the bowl and licking fingers, glad I’m not the only one doing that!) But I can’t find butterscotch chips (or butterscotch at all) in Norwegian grocery stores, so I might have to get creative there…
thank for this tasty n simple recipe. It would be a good addition to my kids’ lunch box.
These are just killing me! They look SO good!
I read this out loud to my daughter and when it said nibble dough, she stopped me and said “Enough said mom we HAVE to make these!” just pray I don’t over bake because I am a pro at that!
why have i never used butterscotch chips before?! holy moly, these look amazing and are totally what I’m making for my husbands birthday this weekend!
These look totally delicious! Best flavour combo!
Holy moly these look and sound delicious, but dangerous lol. I love the sweetness that butterscotch brings to a dish.
Ha! Thanks!
So I made this recipe a couple of days ago for a church lunch. Honestly, I was a little skeptical after I made them because they didn’t look like the picture XD They were round, not flat, and the cookies on the top rack looked burned on top (they were a nice golden on bottom though). Just looking at them, I thought it was a bust.
Turned out though that they tasted really good! Even though they didn’t look as pretty as the picture, they were soft and gooey on the inside and not too sweet. The salt also gave it a nice balance of flavor. After the lunch I came home with only three left, so everyone else seemed to like them too.
Overall, I Iiked the recipe and may try some variations of it soon 🙂
Hi, Kelsey. I’m glad you liked them. Since they didn’t flatten out in the oven, you can slightly flatten them next time. Also, make sure that you don’t overmeasure your flour. I recommend fluffing the flour with a measuring cup, scooping it with the measuring cup and leveling it off with the back of a knife. I appreciate you stopping by to comment.